[ { "caseId": "BL-001", "category": "purchase", "description": "Canonical purchase derives exact integer subtotal.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "create_purchase", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "currency", "jurisdiction", "owner", "provider_calls", "quantity", "registration", "rollback", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:01:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-001", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000001" } }, { "caseId": "BL-002", "category": "provider", "description": "Webhook quantity must match canonical purchase.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "2", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "2", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "INVALID_QUANTITY", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:02:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-002", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000002" } }, { "caseId": "BL-003", "category": "provider", "description": "Webhook amountCents must match canonical purchase.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1499", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1499", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "AMOUNT_MISMATCH", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:03:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-003", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000003" } }, { "caseId": "BL-004", "category": "provider", "description": "Webhook currency must match canonical purchase.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "EUR", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "EUR", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "CURRENCY_MISMATCH", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:04:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-004", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000004" } }, { "caseId": "BL-005", "category": "provider", "description": "Webhook jurisdiction must match canonical purchase.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-NY", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-NY", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "JURISDICTION_MISMATCH", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:05:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-005", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000005" } }, { "caseId": "BL-006", "category": "provider", "description": "Webhook ownerId must match canonical purchase.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.bob", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.bob", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "OWNER_MISMATCH", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:06:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-006", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000006" } }, { "caseId": "BL-007", "category": "provider", "description": "Valid webhook records receipt and economic claim separately.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:07:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-007", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000007" } }, { "caseId": "BL-008", "category": "ordering", "description": "Same event id and same hash is an idempotent replay.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" } ], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "noop", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:08:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-008", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000008" } }, { "caseId": "BL-009", "category": "ordering", "description": "Same event id with a different payload hash is rejected.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" } ], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "payment_webhook", "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "paymentState": "paid", "signatureVerified": true, "taxAmountCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.pay1", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "paid" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "EVENT_PAYLOAD_CONFLICT", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:09:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-009", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000009" } }, { "caseId": "BL-010", "category": "reversal", "description": "Reversal is allocated from cumulative refunded item subtotal with final residual.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" } ], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "refund_webhook", "eventId": "event.ref10", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "refund.obj10", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "500", "kind": "refund", "signatureVerified": true, "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "taxAmountCents": "0", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxRefundedCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.ref10", "objectId": "refund.obj10", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "refunded" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.ref10", "delta": "-1", "reason": "payment_refund_reversal", "ref": { "kind": "reversal", "id": "refund.obj10" } } ], "ledgerNet": "2", "spendableBalance": "2", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" }, { "eventId": "event.ref10", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "refund.obj10", "eventType": "refund_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" }, { "objectId": "refund.obj10", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "refund_reversal" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "500", "reversedCredits": "1" } ] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "cumulative_allocation", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:10:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-010", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000010" } }, { "caseId": "BL-011", "category": "reversal", "description": "Reversal is allocated from cumulative refunded item subtotal with final residual.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } }, { "key": "ledger.ref0", "delta": "-1", "reason": "payment_refund_reversal", "ref": { "kind": "reversal", "id": "refund.obj0" } } ], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" }, { "eventId": "event.ref0", "payloadHash": "bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb", "objectId": "refund.obj0", "eventType": "refund_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" }, { "objectId": "refund.obj0", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "refund_reversal" } ], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "500", "reversedCredits": "1" } ], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "refund_webhook", "eventId": "event.ref11", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "refund.obj11", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "1000", "kind": "refund", "signatureVerified": true, "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "taxAmountCents": "0", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxRefundedCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.ref11", "objectId": "refund.obj11", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "refunded" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.ref11", "delta": "-1", "reason": "payment_refund_reversal", "ref": { "kind": "reversal", "id": "refund.obj11" } } ], "ledgerNet": "1", "spendableBalance": "1", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" }, { "eventId": "event.ref0", "payloadHash": "bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb", "objectId": "refund.obj0", "eventType": "refund_webhook" }, { "eventId": "event.ref11", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "refund.obj11", "eventType": "refund_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" }, { "objectId": "refund.obj0", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "refund_reversal" }, { "objectId": "refund.obj11", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "refund_reversal" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "1000", "reversedCredits": "2" } ] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "cumulative_allocation", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:11:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-011", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000011" } }, { "caseId": "BL-012", "category": "reversal", "description": "Reversal is allocated from cumulative refunded item subtotal with final residual.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } }, { "key": "ledger.ref0", "delta": "-2", "reason": "payment_refund_reversal", "ref": { "kind": "reversal", "id": "refund.obj0" } } ], "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" }, { "eventId": "event.ref0", "payloadHash": "bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb", "objectId": "refund.obj0", "eventType": "refund_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" }, { "objectId": "refund.obj0", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "refund_reversal" } ], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "1000", "reversedCredits": "2" } ], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "refund_webhook", "eventId": "event.ref12", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "refund.obj12", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "1500", "kind": "refund", "signatureVerified": true, "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "taxAmountCents": "0", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxRefundedCents": "0", "providerTruth": { "eventId": "event.ref12", "objectId": "refund.obj12", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "amountCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "taxAmountCents": "0", "paymentState": "refunded" } } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.ref12", "delta": "-1", "reason": "payment_refund_reversal", "ref": { "kind": "reversal", "id": "refund.obj12" } } ], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "3", "unitAmountCents": "500", "itemSubtotalCents": "1500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "receipts": [ { "eventId": "event.pay1", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "payment.obj1", "eventType": "payment_webhook" }, { "eventId": "event.ref0", "payloadHash": "bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb", "objectId": "refund.obj0", "eventType": "refund_webhook" }, { "eventId": "event.ref12", "payloadHash": "aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa", "objectId": "refund.obj12", "eventType": "refund_webhook" } ], "claims": [ { "objectId": "payment.obj1", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "payment_grant" }, { "objectId": "refund.obj0", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "refund_reversal" }, { "objectId": "refund.obj12", "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "effect": "refund_reversal" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [ { "purchaseId": "purchase.p1", "cumulativeRefundedItemSubtotalCents": "1500", "reversedCredits": "3" } ] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "claim", "cumulative_allocation", "currency", "effect", "jurisdiction", "owner", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "provider_event", "provider_object", "quantity", "rollback", "signature", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:12:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-012", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000012" } }, { "caseId": "BL-013", "category": "conversion", "description": "customer funding creates explicit active cycle.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "conversion_accept", "cycleId": "cycle.customer", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "customer", "debit": "1", "idempotencyKey": "submit.customer" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.debit.customer", "delta": "-1", "reason": "conversion_debit", "ref": { "kind": "cycle", "id": "cycle.customer" } } ], "ledgerNet": "2", "spendableBalance": "2", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [ { "cycleId": "cycle.customer", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "customer", "state": "active", "debit": "1", "compensationEligible": true } ], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "effect", "owner", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:13:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-013", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000013" } }, { "caseId": "BL-014", "category": "conversion", "description": "goodwill funding creates explicit active cycle.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "conversion_accept", "cycleId": "cycle.goodwill", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "goodwill", "debit": "1", "idempotencyKey": "submit.goodwill" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.debit.goodwill", "delta": "-1", "reason": "conversion_debit", "ref": { "kind": "cycle", "id": "cycle.goodwill" } } ], "ledgerNet": "2", "spendableBalance": "2", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [ { "cycleId": "cycle.goodwill", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "goodwill", "state": "active", "debit": "1", "compensationEligible": false } ], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "effect", "owner", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:14:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-014", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000014" } }, { "caseId": "BL-015", "category": "conversion", "description": "Only eligible customer debit cycle is compensated once.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } }, { "key": "ledger.debit.customer", "delta": "-1", "reason": "conversion_debit", "ref": { "kind": "cycle", "id": "cycle.customer" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [ { "cycleId": "cycle.customer", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "customer", "state": "active", "debit": "1", "compensationEligible": true } ], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "cycle_failed", "cycleId": "cycle.customer", "failureClass": "terminal" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.comp.customer", "delta": "1", "reason": "cycle_failure_compensation", "ref": { "kind": "cycle", "id": "cycle.customer" } } ], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [ { "cycleId": "cycle.customer", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "customer", "state": "compensated", "debit": "1", "compensationEligible": true } ], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "effect", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:15:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-015", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000015" } }, { "caseId": "BL-016", "category": "conversion", "description": "Goodwill retry failure cannot mint compensation.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [ { "cycleId": "cycle.goodwill", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "goodwill", "state": "active", "debit": "1", "compensationEligible": false } ], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "cycle_failed", "cycleId": "cycle.goodwill", "failureClass": "terminal" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "CYCLE_NOT_ELIGIBLE", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [ { "cycleId": "cycle.goodwill", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "goodwill", "state": "active", "debit": "1", "compensationEligible": false } ], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "effect", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:16:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-016", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000016" } }, { "caseId": "BL-017", "category": "tax", "description": "Expired versioned registration fails closed.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "200", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "201", "databaseNow": "201", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "201", "databaseNow": "201", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "201", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.201" }, "events": [ { "type": "create_purchase", "purchaseId": "purchase.p2", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "quantity": "1", "unitAmountCents": "500", "currency": "USD", "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "registrationVersion": "1", "taxAmountCents": "0", "registrationAuthorizationVersion": "1" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "REGISTRATION_EXPIRED", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "amount", "canonical_purchase", "currency", "jurisdiction", "owner", "provider_calls", "quantity", "registration", "rollback", "tax" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:17:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-017", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000017" } }, { "caseId": "BL-018", "category": "adjustment", "description": "Authorized audited operator adjustment is append-only and idempotent.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [ { "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "operatorId": "operator.senior", "version": "1", "validFrom": "100", "expiresAt": "300", "scopes": [ "support_credit", "fraud_correction", "billing_correction" ], "source": "operator_authorization_registry", "sourceVersion": "7" } ], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "operator_adjustment", "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.a18", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "bc1127cfb4b21ed414d0c6d14f6a55f172bb2e173fd7e2dfef8d7696cd2eccf3" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.adjust.a18", "delta": "2", "reason": "operator_adjustment", "ref": { "kind": "adjustment", "id": "adjustment.a18" } } ], "ledgerNet": "5", "spendableBalance": "5", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [ { "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.a18", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "bc1127cfb4b21ed414d0c6d14f6a55f172bb2e173fd7e2dfef8d7696cd2eccf3", "auditOutcome": "accepted" } ], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "audit", "authorization", "effect", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "accepted" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:18:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-018", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000018" } }, { "caseId": "BL-019", "category": "adjustment", "description": "Authorized audited operator adjustment is append-only and idempotent.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [ { "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "operatorId": "operator.senior", "version": "1", "validFrom": "100", "expiresAt": "300", "scopes": [ "support_credit", "fraud_correction", "billing_correction" ], "source": "operator_authorization_registry", "sourceVersion": "7" } ], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "operator_adjustment", "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a19", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "-1", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "billing_correction", "auditRecordId": "audit.a19", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a19", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "a010c96473d78856b901bf90323b920c7c8b9130de15e2cf6b6bc93afb0b9654" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "accepted", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.adjust.a19", "delta": "-1", "reason": "operator_adjustment", "ref": { "kind": "adjustment", "id": "adjustment.a19" } } ], "ledgerNet": "2", "spendableBalance": "2", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [ { "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a19", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "-1", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "billing_correction", "auditRecordId": "audit.a19", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a19", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "a010c96473d78856b901bf90323b920c7c8b9130de15e2cf6b6bc93afb0b9654", "auditOutcome": "accepted" } ], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "audit", "authorization", "effect", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "accepted" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:19:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-019", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000019" } }, { "caseId": "BL-020", "category": "adjustment", "description": "Adjustment replay by idempotency key is a no-op.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } }, { "key": "ledger.adjust.a18", "delta": "2", "reason": "operator_adjustment", "ref": { "kind": "adjustment", "id": "adjustment.a18" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [ { "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.a18", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "bc1127cfb4b21ed414d0c6d14f6a55f172bb2e173fd7e2dfef8d7696cd2eccf3", "auditOutcome": "accepted" } ], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [ { "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "operatorId": "operator.senior", "version": "1", "validFrom": "100", "expiresAt": "300", "scopes": [ "support_credit", "fraud_correction", "billing_correction" ], "source": "operator_authorization_registry", "sourceVersion": "7" } ], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "operator_adjustment", "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.a18", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "bc1127cfb4b21ed414d0c6d14f6a55f172bb2e173fd7e2dfef8d7696cd2eccf3" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "noop", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "5", "spendableBalance": "5", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [ { "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.a18", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "bc1127cfb4b21ed414d0c6d14f6a55f172bb2e173fd7e2dfef8d7696cd2eccf3", "auditOutcome": "accepted" } ], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "audit", "authorization", "effect", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "replay_same_hash_noop" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:20:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-020", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000020" } }, { "caseId": "BL-021", "category": "adjustment", "description": "Unauthorized adjustment is rejected without audit or ledger mutation.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "operator_adjustment", "adjustmentId": "adjustment.bad", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.untrusted", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.bad", "idempotencyKey": "idem.bad", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "adca83a5a72d2f5827611aef8d1936f9e7ff64967e5388c8b7c420b8056e2a74" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "ADJUSTMENT_UNAUTHORIZED", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "audit", "authorization", "effect", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "unauthorized_rejected" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:21:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-021", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000021" } }, { "caseId": "BL-022", "category": "ordering", "description": "Competing final-credit requests have exactly one correlated winner.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.one", "delta": "1", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "conversion_accept", "cycleId": "cycle.race", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "customer", "debit": "1", "idempotencyKey": "request.a" }, { "type": "conversion_accept", "cycleId": "cycle.race", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "customer", "debit": "1", "idempotencyKey": "request.b" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "correlated", "error": null, "ledgerAppends": [ { "key": "ledger.race", "delta": "-1", "reason": "conversion_debit", "ref": { "kind": "cycle", "id": "cycle.race" } } ], "ledgerNet": "0", "spendableBalance": "0", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [ { "cycleId": "cycle.race", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "fundingKind": "customer", "state": "active", "debit": "1", "compensationEligible": true } ], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": { "constraint": "exactly_one_correlated_winner", "alternatives": [ { "label": "request.a", "outcome": "accepted", "cycleId": "cycle.race", "submissionId": "request.a", "jobId": "job.race", "effectKey": "ledger.race" }, { "label": "request.b", "outcome": "rejected", "cycleId": null, "submissionId": "request.b", "jobId": null, "effectKey": null } ], "matchingWinner": "request.a", "jobId": "job.race", "effectKey": "ledger.race" }, "assertions": [ "amount", "effect", "owner", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "none" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:22:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-022", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000022" } }, { "caseId": "BL-023", "category": "adjustment", "description": "Expired operator authorization is rejected with an exact audit outcome.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [ { "authorizationId": "auth.expired", "operatorId": "operator.senior", "version": "1", "validFrom": "100", "expiresAt": "300", "scopes": [ "support_credit" ], "source": "operator_authorization_registry", "sourceVersion": "7" } ], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "operator_adjustment", "adjustmentId": "adjustment.bad", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.bad", "idempotencyKey": "idem.bad", "authorizationId": "auth.expired", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "400", "payloadHash": "1109d9f47d33796502f1ddca2cedbfa24759967cb9be4b1010c9eb4acaf50185" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "ADJUSTMENT_UNAUTHORIZED", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "audit", "authorization", "effect", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "expired_rejected" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:23:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-023", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000023" } }, { "caseId": "BL-024", "category": "adjustment", "description": "Malformed zero-delta adjustment is rejected with an exact audit outcome.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [ { "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "operatorId": "operator.senior", "version": "1", "validFrom": "100", "expiresAt": "300", "scopes": [ "support_credit" ], "source": "operator_authorization_registry", "sourceVersion": "7" } ], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "operator_adjustment", "adjustmentId": "adjustment.bad", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "0", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.bad", "idempotencyKey": "idem.bad", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "5da0281526b60fed1fa27bca17b31ac108cd7e0689b0d135cb492f67917a3c2c" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "ADJUSTMENT_INVALID", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "3", "spendableBalance": "3", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "audit", "authorization", "effect", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "malformed_rejected" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:24:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-024", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000024" } }, { "caseId": "BL-025", "category": "adjustment", "description": "Adjustment replay with same key and different payload hash is rejected and audited.", "initial": { "ledgerBefore": [ { "key": "ledger.grant1", "delta": "3", "reason": "payment_grant", "ref": { "kind": "purchase", "id": "purchase.p1" } }, { "key": "ledger.adjust.a18", "delta": "2", "reason": "operator_adjustment", "ref": { "kind": "adjustment", "id": "adjustment.a18" } } ], "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "registrations": [ { "jurisdiction": "US-CA", "version": "1", "expiresAt": "999", "taxEvidenceId": "tax.ev1", "authenticatedBy": "tax.admin", "validFrom": "100", "evaluatedAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "authorizationSourceVersion": "1" } ], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [ { "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.a18", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "bc1127cfb4b21ed414d0c6d14f6a55f172bb2e173fd7e2dfef8d7696cd2eccf3", "auditOutcome": "accepted" } ], "evaluationAt": "200", "databaseNow": "200", "refundStates": [], "operatorAuthorizations": [ { "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "operatorId": "operator.senior", "version": "1", "validFrom": "100", "expiresAt": "300", "scopes": [ "support_credit", "fraud_correction", "billing_correction" ], "source": "operator_authorization_registry", "sourceVersion": "7" } ], "authoritativeJurisdictionTime": "200", "trustedTimeReceiptId": "time.receipt.200" }, "events": [ { "type": "operator_adjustment", "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "3", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.conflict", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "00f94b0227792d584a082a9c28b716213c81595c465084b0f872766b40490c47" } ], "expected": { "outcome": "rejected", "error": "EVENT_PAYLOAD_CONFLICT", "ledgerAppends": [], "ledgerNet": "5", "spendableBalance": "5", "deficit": "0", "state": { "purchases": [], "receipts": [], "claims": [], "cycles": [], "adjustments": [ { "adjustmentId": "adjustment.a18", "ownerId": "owner.alice", "delta": "2", "authorizedBy": "operator.senior", "reasonCode": "support_credit", "auditRecordId": "audit.a18", "idempotencyKey": "idem.a18", "authorizationId": "auth.senior", "authorizationVersion": "1", "authorizationSourceVersion": "7", "requestedAt": "200", "payloadHash": "bc1127cfb4b21ed414d0c6d14f6a55f172bb2e173fd7e2dfef8d7696cd2eccf3", "auditOutcome": "accepted" } ], "refundStates": [] }, "winner": null, "assertions": [ "audit", "authorization", "effect", "payload_hash", "provider_calls", "rollback" ], "providerCalls": "0", "auditOutcome": "replay_different_hash_rejected" }, "evidenceMetadata": { "observedAt": "2026-08-23T12:25:00Z", "sourceUri": "https://evidence.press.zone/billing/BL-025", "ownerEmail": "billing-owner@press.zone", "traceId": "00000000-0000-4000-8000-000000000025" } } ]